When Jake insists on cooking Thanksgiving turkey for the first time, Jen is skeptical but supportive until the result is a culinary disaster no one at the table can ignore. But the real shock comes when she discovers the recipe isn’t Jake’s. As tensions simmer and doubts creep in, she’s forced to confront the cracks in their marriage. This Thanksgiving, the turkey isn’t the only thing leaving a bad aftertaste.
Thanksgiving has always been my domain. I’m not saying I’m Martha Stewart in any way, but the turkey? That’s my masterpiece.
So when Jake, my husband of six years, announced he’d be taking the reins this year, I was caught off guard.
A woman standing in the kitchen | Source: Midjourney
“This year, I’m cooking the turkey,” he declared over dinner one night, his tone brimming with confidence.
“I’ve got a secret recipe, Jen…”
I smiled at him, though something about the way he said secret made my stomach do a little flip.
“Alright,” I said, keeping my tone light. “I’ll put my feet up, maybe do my nails. Just let me know if you need any help.”
A man sitting at a dinner table | Source: Midjourney
“I won’t,” he shot back quickly.
Too quickly.
“This is going to be special.”
Jake’s always been eager to impress. At work, with his friends, his mother — especially his mother. And Patricia’s the type of woman who finds fault in compliments. She’d call the Mona Lisa “a little boring.”
A woman drinking a glass of wine | Source: Midjourney
The morning of Thanksgiving, Jake was a man possessed. He’d woken up early to prep, shooing me out of the kitchen before I could even pour my coffee.
“I’ve got it under control,” he chirped.
Patricia, perched at the counter with her ever-present glass of wine, raised a skeptical eyebrow.
A coffee machine | Source: Midjourney
“Jen, are you sure this is a good idea?” she asked me, her voice dripping with faux concern. “You’ve always done the turkey so well.”
“It’ll be fine,” I muttered, more to myself than to her.
Hours later, Jake emerged from the kitchen with our Thanksgiving centerpiece. To his credit, it looked perfect. Golden-brown, glistening, straight out of a food magazine or blog. He had even made roasted vegetables, mashed potatoes, cranberry sauce, and a thick gravy.
A Thanksgiving turkey | Source: Midjourney
My mom clapped enthusiastically. Patricia tilted her head, inspecting it like a jeweler appraising a diamond.
“It smells amazing!” my mom gushed.
We gathered around the table, Jake beaming as he carved the first slice. Music was being played, plates were passed, and soon everyone had a helping. I cut into mine, ready to be caught off guard by the delicious meal.
People sitting around a table | Source: Midjourney
The moment it hit my tongue, I gagged.
“What the…?” I coughed, reaching for my water.
It wasn’t savory. It wasn’t even remotely turkey-like. It was sweet. Sickeningly, cloyingly sweet, like someone had glazed it with melted candy or something.
“Jake,” I managed, staring at him in disbelief. “What is this?”
A woman holding a napkin to her mouth | Source: Midjourney
Patricia, mid-chew, spat hers into a napkin with dramatic flair.
“Oh, Jake. Oh no.”
Jake’s face flushed red.
“It’s a glaze!” he said defensively. “Brown sugar, maple syrup, and marshmallow fluff. It’s different! It’s creative!”
A woman holding napkin to her mouth | Source: Midjourney
“Creative?” I echoed. “It tastes like someone dropped a turkey in a vat of something at Willy Wonka’s factory.”
The room fell silent. My brother-in-law, Steven, stifled a laugh. My mom pretended to focus on her mashed potatoes. Patricia, never one to miss an opportunity, shook her head with a dramatic sigh.
“This is why we don’t mess with tradition, Jake. Since you got married, Jen’s been the turkey girl. Tradition, Jake. Tradition.”
A woman sitting at a table with a glass of wine | Source: Midjourney
Jake’s jaw tightened at her comment, but he stayed quiet. I noticed his hand twitch toward the wine bottle. Like he wanted to grab it and drown out the awkwardness with some good old fermented grapes.
Later, after most of our guests had shuffled home and Jake had retreated to the den to lick his wounds, I stayed behind to clean the kitchen.
“Don’t worry about it, honey,” I said. “You chill in there, and I’ll be with you soon. I stashed a pumpkin pie earlier, because I know we like it with cold whipped cream.”
A slice of pumpkin pie and whipped cream | Source: Midjourney
I was trying to be nice. To help him realize that it had been a mistake, and nothing was wrong with that.
As I tossed scraps into the trash, a crumpled piece of paper caught my eye. Curious, I smoothed it out, revealing a handwritten recipe.
My heart sped up when I saw the name at the bottom of the page.
Sarah.
The contents of a trash can | Source: Midjourney
Sarah. Jake’s ex-wife.
My hands trembled as I stared at the card. Of all the people Jake could have gone to for a recipe — Google searches included — why on earth would he choose her? My mind worked overtime, trying to connect dots I didn’t want to see.
I stormed into the living room, holding the recipe card like evidence. Jake looked up from his football game rerun, his face draining of color.
A man sitting in front of a TV | Source: Midjourney
“Care to explain this?” I asked, my voice colder than I intended.
Jake sat up straighter.
“I… uh… I just wanted to make something special, Jen. Sarah worked as a cook for a while, when she was into catering. And I thought she’d… you know… have some good ideas for me.”
A woman in a kitchen | Source: Midjourney
“You thought Sarah would have the answer?” I interrupted, my voice rising. “Not me, your wife, the person who has been cooking almost all of your meals, Thanksgiving and Christmas dinners included, for years?”
Jake’s mouth opened, then closed. For once, he had no response.
“I just… I didn’t want to mess up,” he admitted finally, his voice barely above a whisper. “You’re so good at it, and I thought if I asked, you’d take over. I wanted to prove that I could do it all on my own.”
A man holding his head | Source: Midjourney
“And you couldn’t just ask me for a little help?” I snapped. “Not even for my suggestions? Instead, you went to your ex-wife?”
Jake winced.
“Jen, it wasn’t like that…”
“No?” I shot back. “Then what was it like?”
A woman with her hands on her hips | Source: Midjourney
As I lay staring at the ceiling that night, my mind wouldn’t stop spiraling. Jake’s explanation felt weak. If he was too insecure to ask for my help with a turkey, what did that say about our relationship?
And Sarah?
Why her?
Was she really his best option, or was something else behind it? I mean, if I’m being honest, people always say you remember your first love forever.
A woman laying in bed at night | Source: Midjourney
The next morning, Jake approached me with a mug of coffee and a slice of pumpkin pie.
“I’m sorry,” he said softly. “I’m really sorry, love. I wasn’t thinking. I just wanted to impress everyone, and I… I messed up royally.”
I nodded, keeping calm and collected, as I had instructed myself all night. I could barely sleep with my mind running through the possibilities.
A cup of coffee and a slice of pie | Source: Midjourney
“I understand wanting to impress people, Jake. But here’s the thing — next time you want advice, like good, solid advice, maybe start with the person you married. And for the record? Sarah sabotaged you. This recipe? Unless it was for some sickly sweet cereal treat, it was revenge, plain and simple.”
Jake blinked, his mouth dropping open.
“You think…”
A man looking shocked | Source: Midjourney
“Oh, I don’t think, Jake,” I said firmly. “I know.”
He groaned, sinking into the nearest chair.
“Goodness, I’m such an idiot.”
Jake couldn’t seem to meet my eyes for the rest of Thanksgiving weekend. He apologized again, twice, but it didn’t erase the lingering doubt. I kept replaying the moment I found that recipe card and the look on his face when I confronted him.
A man looking apologetic | Source: Midjourney
Patricia, of course, added fuel to the fire. She was staying with us for the weekend and naturally had heard everything.
“Well, at least he learned his lesson,” she remarked with a smug sip of her wine.
Jake had decided to take our dog for a walk, leaving Patricia and me alone, dissecting the entire turkey fiasco.
A man with his dog | Source: Midjourney
“Do you really think he went to her for help?” I asked my mother-in-law. “That there is nothing else going on?”
“Darling, Sarah cheated on him. She broke his little heart, so it can’t be anything more. I think our foolish man just wanted to impress the women in his life, so he reached out to the only other one he knew well.”
“I’m doubting everything.” I admitted, picking up Patricia’s glass of wine and taking a sip.
A woman holding a glass of wine | Source: Midjourney
“Jen, he adores you. He’s just a bit stupid sometimes. But if you think that a bigger and more important conversation needs to be had, then go ahead, darling. Do it.”
I nodded.
By Sunday night, I was exhausted — emotionally, mentally, physically. That Thanksgiving turkey didn’t just leave a bad taste in my mouth. It left cracks in something I thought was solid.
A woman sitting on a porch | Source: Midjourney
The truth is, I don’t know if I’ll ever fully trust Jake’s judgment again. Not just in the kitchen but in everything. And as we lay in bed that night, his soft apology didn’t make those doubts disappear.
For now, I’m still here. But I can’t shake the feeling that something shifted this Thanksgiving, and once things crack, it’s hard to piece them back together again.
A couple standing in a kitchen | Source: Midjourney
What would you have done?
If you’ve enjoyed this story, here’s another one for you |
At Christmas Dinner, My Daughter Stood up and Shouted, ‘And Where’s the Man Mom Keeps in Our Basement?’
Over a family dinner with his wife, daughter, and extended family, Quentin thinks everything will be perfect in the Christmas wonderland his wife has created. But during dinner, Daphne, his daughter, claims there’s a man hidden in their basement. Quentin has no choice but to uncover the truth.
Christmas dinner was supposed to be perfect this year. My wife, Ivy, had spent weeks transforming our home into a holiday wonderland, from garlands framing the doorways to twinkling white lights strung across the windows.
A house decorated for Christmas | Source: Midjourney
Our 8-year-old daughter, Daphne, had helped set the table, her chaotic but charming touch evident in the mismatched napkin folds and slightly tilted name cards.
Both sets of grandparents were with us, this being Ivy’s first Christmas with her stepfather, Patrick. Everyone was laughing, trading stories, and sipping mulled wine. For once, everything felt harmonious.
Until Daphne destroyed it all.
A smiling little girl | Source: Midjourney
I was mid-slice into the turkey, the knife gliding through the golden, crispy skin, when Daphne climbed onto her chair.
This work is inspired by real events and people, but it has been fictionalized for creative purposes. Names, characters, and details have been changed to protect privacy and enhance the narrative. Any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, or actual events is purely coincidental and not intended by the author.
The author and publisher make no claims to the accuracy of events or the portrayal of characters and are not liable for any misinterpretation. This story is provided “as is,” and any opinions expressed are those of the characters and do not reflect the views of the author or publisher.
I Took an Abandoned Girl from Church on Easter Only to Uncover My MIL’s Deepest Secret — Story of the Day
She was five. Alone. Holding an Easter basket on the church steps. I brought her home against my MIL’s protests. By evening, I realized this child wasn’t a stranger to our family at all.
I don’t like celebrating Easter with my husband’s family.
It’s not the holiday itself — it’s beautiful, bright, full of the smell of yeasty dough and fresh flowers. But celebrating it under my MIL’s sharp gaze feels like sitting on needles in a lace dress.
To her, I’ve always been a little “not right.”
For illustration purposes only | Source: Pexels
So when my husband, Dave, suggested going to her place, I made every effort not to grimace. He was drying his hands with a towel, clearly hoping I’d say “yes” without hesitation this time.
“Come on, love. It’ll be nice.”
I sat at the kitchen table with a cup of tea that had long gone cold.
For illustration purposes only | Source: Pexels
“You know exactly how it’ll go,” I murmured without looking up.
“She’s trying,” Dave said softly. “She even decorated the terrace with flowers. Says she’s making it just like when I was a kid.”
“Yeah. With the same ‘jokes’ from back then — like how you’re still childless because your wife clearly can’t bake anything more meaningful than a cake.”
Dave let out a slow breath. Silent. Not denying it.
For illustration purposes only | Source: Pexels
“She doesn’t know,” he said after a pause.
“And she doesn’t need to. It’s our business. Not hers.”
Dave nodded. But I saw it in his eyes — the weariness. The way he’d grown tired of being the rope in a silent tug-of-war between two women who loved him in different ways.
For illustration purposes only | Source: Pexels
I turned to the window. Crocuses had started blooming. Easter was around the corner.
“Fine,” I stood up. “Let’s go. Better her decorated terrace than our walls reminding us of what we don’t have.”
“You sure?”
“No,” I smiled. “But I have a nice dress. It deserves some air.”
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
Dave laughed and raised his hands in surrender.
“So are we blessing the Easter basket or just keeping the peace for one day?”
“Don’t get ahead of yourself until I’m actually holding the basket,” I grumbled, pulling on my coat.
An hour later, we were driving down a road sprinkled with fallen blossoms. I had no idea this Easter would be more challenging than I expected.
For illustration purposes only | Source: Pexels
***
The morning went surprisingly well. Cynthia greeted us without a single eye roll or poisonous comment.
The Easter service was beautiful.
Light streamed through the stained-glass windows, and I found myself almost relaxed, sitting beside Dave with Cynthia on the other side, clutching her blessed basket like a relic.
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
No side-eyes. No sighs. No carefully sharpened remarks. For the first time ever, it felt like a normal holiday. A quiet, uneventful, even… pleasant Easter. At least, that’s what I thought.
When the service ended, we stepped out into the sunlight. I stood near Dave’s mother as she scanned the crowd.
“Where’s David? Still in there?”
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
“He’s helping someone with the candles.”
Cynthia muttered something under her breath and headed toward the car. I was about to follow when…
I saw her.
A little girl, no older than five, was sitting alone on the edge of the stone steps. Her Easter basket rested beside her — jelly beans inside, and a chocolate bunny with one ear already bitten off.
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
She was Black. Dressed in a white cardigan and yellow dress, her shoes perfectly polished. But her face looked… abandoned.
I walked over slowly and crouched down.
“Hey there. Are you waiting for someone?”
She looked up. Big brown eyes. Calm, but uncertain.
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
“My daddy. Mama said he’d be here to get me.”
“You came here alone?”
She shook her head.
“Mom brought me. She said Daddy would come.”
Before I could ask more, I heard a sharp voice behind me.
For illustration purposes only | Source: Pexels
“There you are!” Cynthia’s heels clicked against the pavement. “What on earth are you doing? We’re all waiting in the car!”
“This little girl… She’s waiting for her father. Says he’s supposed to meet her here.”
Cynthia gave her a long look, unimpressed. “Oh, come on. You don’t really believe that.”
“She seems sure. Maybe we could check with someone? Or let the priest know?”
For illustration purposes only | Source: Pexels
Cynthia rolled her eyes.
“She seems like she walked away from some social worker. You don’t just leave a five-year-old at church with a basket and expect a miracle.”
Then, she narrowed her eyes at me, already sensing where that was going.
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
“And don’t even think about getting involved. You’re not bringing some stranger’s child into someone’s clean home on Easter Sunday.”
“She’s not a kitten. She’s a child. Alone. I’m not leaving her here.”
“She’ll be fine!” Cynthia snapped. “Someone will come for her. It’s a church, not a bus stop.”
I looked down. The girl had gone quiet.
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
“I’ll take her with us,” I said.
“You will not.” Cynthia’s voice went cold. “This is my house. I decide who walks through my door.”
“Then Dave and I will get a hotel.”
“You’re being ridiculous.”
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
I knelt again beside the girl.
“What’s your name, sweetheart?”
“Ava,” she whispered.
“Well, Ava, how about you come with us for a little while? Just until we find your Mom or Dad, okay?”
She nodded.
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
Dave appeared just as I was scribbling our address on the back of a church flyer and handing it to the priest. Cynthia stormed toward him.
“Your wife is bringing home strays now!”
Dave looked at me, then at Ava, then at his mother.
“It’s fine,” he said calmly. “She can come with us.”
“She what? David!”
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
“She’s a little girl, Mom. It’s Easter.”
Cynthia stared at both of us like we’d lost our minds. But I held Ava’s hand as we walked to the car. And Dave didn’t let go of mine.
I had no idea who that child truly was.
But something deep inside me already knew — that wasn’t random.
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
***
Ava followed me through the hallway in tiny socks, carefully stepping on the wooden floor like it might crack beneath her.
The house smelled like Easter bread and tension.
Cynthia hadn’t said a word since we came in. She’d pursed her lips so tight I thought they might disappear entirely.
For illustration purposes only | Source: Pexels
Dave, bless him, tried to smooth things over — making tea, chatting about traffic, pretending we hadn’t just brought a mysterious child into his childhood home.
But Ava was… different.
She didn’t whine. Didn’t ask for cartoons. She just sat at the table drawing, focused, quiet. Her tiny fingers gripped a purple crayon like it was the only anchor she had.
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
I leaned over.
“That’s beautiful. Who is it?”
She held up the drawing — a man, a woman, and a little girl between them. They were holding hands.
The man had brown hair and green eyes. Just like Dave.
I swallowed hard.
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
“You like drawing your mom and dad?”
She nodded.
“Sometimes I dream about them. Together.”
I stood and quietly went to the guest room where we’d placed her backpack. I needed to find her toothbrush. Or clean socks. Or anything — just something to do with my hands.
For illustration purposes only | Source: Pexels
I unzipped the side pocket. A photo slipped out. It fluttered to the floor.
I bent down. And froze. It was a printed photo. A young couple, smiling.
The woman — beautiful, dark-skinned, with soft curls around her cheeks. The man — tall, white, with familiar green eyes.
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
Familiar face.
Familiar jawline.
Familiar dimple.
My husband!
For illustration purposes only | Source: Pexels
“Ava?” I called gently, stepping into the hallway.
She peeked out from the kitchen, chewing on a cookie. I showed her the photo.
“Sweetheart… Who’s this?”
She smiled brightly.
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
“That’s my mommy and daddy!”
I tried to return the smile. But my cheeks refused to move.
“Do you know your daddy’s name?”
She paused. “I think… David. I’ve never met him.”
My heart dropped.
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
I nodded slowly and turned down the hallway, my fingers trembling around the photo.
Then, the soft creak of a floorboard behind me. A sigh.
Cynthia.
She was already standing there, arms folded, eyes narrowed like she’d been waiting for her cue. I stepped into the living room where Dave sat on the couch, holding out the photo.
“Dave. What is this?”
For illustration purposes only | Source: Pexels
My husband looked up. His face went pale. Before he could speak, Cynthia’s voice cut through the air like ice.
“Oh, for God’s sake,” she snapped, striding into the room. “I heard everything. First, you bring home a random child, now you’re accusing my son of being her father? What kind of circus is this?”
Dave stood up.
“Mom. Stop.”
For illustration purposes only | Source: Pexels
Cynthia’s eyes burned into mine.
“You’re seriously turning Easter into some twisted drama? What’s next — a baby goat in the guest room?”
Dave didn’t look at her. He took my hand.
“She might be my daughter.”
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
***
The house held its breath.
Dave sat on the armrest of the couch, staring at the photo in his hand like it was ticking. Cynthia paced near the fireplace, arms crossed so tightly her knuckles turned white.
Ava was upstairs, drawing. Quiet as a ghost. And just as heavy on our hearts. Then the doorbell rang. We all froze. Cynthia frowned.
“Who could that possibly be?”
For illustration purposes only | Source: Pexels
Dave looked at me. I didn’t say anything — just headed toward the door, my palms damp.
When I opened it, I saw her.
A tall woman stood on the porch. Black. Graceful. The wind tugged at her scarf, revealing soft curls and sharp cheekbones. Her eyes were tired.
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
It took me only a second to place her. She was the woman from the photo. The one smiling beside Dave in the snapshot, hidden in Ava’s backpack.
The one who hadn’t said a word. Until now.
“Hi,” she said softly. “You must be the one who brought Ava.”
I nodded.
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
“I’m Daisy,” she added. “Her mother.”
I stepped aside without speaking. She entered slowly, like someone stepping into a house that once belonged to her in a dream.
Dave stood up the moment he saw her.
“Daisy…?”
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
“I got your number from the priest. But I didn’t call. I already knew where to go.”
“You knew we’d be here?”
“I didn’t… not until I saw you this morning. At the church.”
Dave froze.
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
“I was walking past with Ava,” she continued. “We were just going to sit outside and listen to the choir. But then Ava saw you. She didn’t know it was you. I did.”
Daisy’s voice trembled, just slightly.
“Ava always asks about you. I didn’t plan anything. But I thought…”
She paused. Looked around the room.
For illustration purposes only | Source: Pexels
“I told her to wait for her Dad.”
“You left her?” Cynthia’s voice cut like broken glass.
“I stayed,” Daisy said, turning sharply. “I watched everything. You were one of the last families to leave. I wanted to see what you’d do. Whether you’d ignore her. Whether you’d walk away.”
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
Dave looked like he was about to fall.
“You should have told me.”
“I tried. Twice. The first time, I got your voicemail. The second… your mother answered the door. After that, your number stopped working.”
All heads turned to Cynthia. She didn’t flinch. But her mouth was tight.
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
“I was protecting you,” she said.
“No,” Daisy replied. “You were protecting yourself. Your image. Your control.”
“I was protecting my son’s future!”
“You stole his present. And his daughter’s.”
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
Dave’s face crumbled. He turned to me, searching, as if for balance.
I stepped forward and said quietly, “She’s not trying to break anything, Cynthia. She’s trying to give something back.”
Then we heard the footsteps. Ava appeared at the top of the stairs, holding a piece of paper.
“Mommy?”
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
Daisy’s entire face changed. She crouched without thinking.
“Hey, baby.”
Ava ran to her, curling into her arms like she’d been waiting for this hug her whole life. Dave’s voice broke the silence.
“I didn’t know. God, I didn’t know.”
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
“You do now,” Daisy answered gently. “And she’s right here.”
Dave looked at me. I reached for his hand.
“She’s your daughter. I’m not going anywhere. But neither is she.”
Cynthia stood still. I turned to her.
“I may never be able to give you a grandchild. But you already have one. Maybe not the one you imagined. But real. Brilliant. Here.”
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
Cynthia didn’t answer. But something shifted in her eyes. She looked at Ava, and her shoulders dropped.
“You can stay,” she said hoarsely. “All of you. It’s Easter. And I guess… even the messiest families deserve to be together.”
Ava stepped toward me and unfolded her drawing.
“I made us all. Even Granny Cynthia. Just in case.”
Cynthia blinked. For a second, I thought she might cry. She cleared her throat.
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
“That’s… very sweet, dear.”
Ava smiled shyly and returned to Daisy’s side. And I… I just watched them. A man. A woman. A child. A mess. A miracle. A maybe.
Maybe our family didn’t begin the way we hoped. Maybe it was twisted, tangled, and painful.
But it was real. It was ours. And somehow, in the most unexpected way, I’d found someone I didn’t even know I was meant to love.
For illustration purposes only | Source: Midjourney
Tell us what you think about this story, and share it with your friends. It might inspire them and brighten their day.
Leave a Reply